This post is part of a series – click ‘previous’ or ‘next’ at the bottom of this page for more.
There’s a sliding scale at play: the more you hit [and the better the metrics], the more you can get away with defensively and vice versa.
If you have an exit velocity of 103 mph and bat speed of 82 mph, it should be fine if a lack of speed & arm strength limits you to First-base or DH only. And even if you aren’t a spectacular defender there, you’re still likely going to get opportunities.
On the flip side, if you have below-average hitting metrics, swing or production (or some combo of those 3), you’ll likely have to be a true premium defender at a premium position to truly get an opportunity to play. This below-average offensive profile combined with a corner-only defensive profile/fit would be problematic from a coaches perspective.